Laughter, tears, sweat and yummy treats! What a week it has been being a parent working from home with whānau also working and learning from home.
This blogpost is a bit different as it is from my perspective as a parent and reflects our experiences as a family. We are pleased with both our children's schools and how they are rising to the challenge of teaching from home. However, there are always new learnings, and I hope this post encourages some reflection.
We have had, on the whole, three good days of learning. My wife has developed a much better understanding of Year 6 maths, Year 11 Science and Yr 8 code-breaking.
Working and learning at home is beginning to be the new normal. I often work at home and usually have a family at home when I am working; however, this is different as they are also working and require support as well. My wife is learning to work in a cloud-based environment, and the kids are learning a whole heap of new skills to organise and navigate learning online, and all have required a lot of support before the holiday break.
It has been fascinating seeing how my two children are entirely different when it comes to their planning of the organisation for learning.
My daughter loves her timetable
This blogpost is a bit different as it is from my perspective as a parent and reflects our experiences as a family. We are pleased with both our children's schools and how they are rising to the challenge of teaching from home. However, there are always new learnings, and I hope this post encourages some reflection.
We have had, on the whole, three good days of learning. My wife has developed a much better understanding of Year 6 maths, Year 11 Science and Yr 8 code-breaking.
Working and learning at home is beginning to be the new normal. I often work at home and usually have a family at home when I am working; however, this is different as they are also working and require support as well. My wife is learning to work in a cloud-based environment, and the kids are learning a whole heap of new skills to organise and navigate learning online, and all have required a lot of support before the holiday break.
It has been fascinating seeing how my two children are entirely different when it comes to their planning of the organisation for learning.
My daughter loves her timetable
It was a bit surprising how she took it so literally and got upset when she went over her brain break by four minutes and missed four minutes of maths!
My son has struggled with a lack of structure for his learning. The expectation is to use his normal timetable; however, this has been problematic as all the subjects have used different platforms Hapara Workspace, Google Classroom, Education Perfect, My Maths, MangaHigh and email. There is no one place where all of his learning can be accessed.
To support my son we have had to sit down and go through all the separate Google Classrooms (there are six of them), the Workspace, emails and Education perfect and centralise the tasks that require completion.
My son and I sat down and planned for the last three days of term 1 and created his timetable with links to the work from that list.
Unfortunately, this first draft just stressed my son out with all the work he had to do and the times he had to do it.
For term two we then looked at creating more of a checklist that had no time allocations and broke the tasks down into smaller chunks.
The new checklist once printed out so he could have it beside him on the desk has been excellent for my son, and he has quietly and confidently worked through the tasks and marked them off on the sheet.
My learnings as a parent
- It takes time to establish how your child organises their day to learn and requires a number of options for your child to choose from to support the planning of their day/week.
- There needs to be multiple ways available to them for choosing how to organise their day.
- Schools need to limit the links or spaces children need to access their learning. A one-page organiser or list linked to the learning tasks could be helpful to help the student organise the day/week. Some form of this may need to be created by the school, which would also help teachers coordinate workload across classes?
- Edited 18 April - We have found the one stop shop it is called mystudentdashboard.com. If your school uses Hapara Teacher Dashboard this is part of the package. My son logged into it and sure enough it brings Hapara Workspace and Google Classroom all into one place. Yay! We will now be able to find everything easily and my son can then organise his own timetable.
- There needs to be coordination by teachers and leaders, especially in High School due to the individual nature of subjects, to ensure workload is responsible.
I do selfishly hope this continues for a few more weeks to give teachers, students and whānau a real feel for learning that can be more empowering, ubiquitous and visible.
Thanks for sharing, Mark. I was nodding along as I read your post, having had a very similar experience with my daughter and son - completely opposite approaches. I agree with you about hoping we have a little more time to embed this way of learning, the teenagers are thriving on the fact that they can sleep in until 11am because that is what they negotiated as part of planning their routines. It's definitely making me question a lot of the structures I have always taken for granted before.
ReplyDeleteThank you Cam, this time is certainly challenging many assumptions and ways of working for many areas not only education. I am not sure how you replicate sleeping in to 11am when we are back to school, however would it not be cool for students to have the choice to work half their day at school and half at home if they so choose.
DeleteSome interesting questions posed. Where does learner agency and autonomy fit into this take? There seems to be much responsibility on the school implied for not providing a minute by minute timetable as a criticism for your second learner. Is it realistic to expect that schools within the 4 days given to prepare for distance learning to have developed new and differentsystems if they were already google classroom based schools? Further to that would creating a new one stop shop system that is removed from learning modes that learners used prior be helpful or harmful? Many primary schools operate in a home room type environment like your first example but most secondary schools do not. Is this a sector difference? Great reflection on what did and did not work for your learners. Does this dictate the approach for all? Is the fact that one of your learners initially struggled with the change from in class instruction and then found a way that worked for him to approach learning in this context not a positive in terms of their personal learning Is negotiating struggle an important part of learning?
ReplyDeleteKia ora,
DeleteThank you for taking the time to read and comment on my blog post. My apologies if it feels I am pointing the finger at the school for failing my child, this is not correct as I think this particular school has done exceptionally well to prepare the staff and students for the learning at home. The majority of the activities are fun and engaging for my son. My son has found aspects of planning his days and weeks hard and like you say it has allowed him and myself an opportunity to learn what works best for him.
My focus is not on the lack of a minute by minute timetable for my son (both my son and I would not have enjoyed that) or changing all the systems the school have in place. It is more about having an overview of all the learning tasks available in one place where then the students can take ownership and plan their own day/week. With collaborative programs, surely this is a possibility?
I also wonder why do we have these sector differences, why does learning change from primary into secondary and onto tertiary? With the rebuilds going on in the sector across New Zealand, I wonder if these differences will be less apparent over time?
I am certainly not advocating one approach for learners however this blog post is a reflection about my children and our family. I do wonder if families that are not aware of the scaffolds they could use to help plan with their students how they are coping?
There have been so many learnings over the last few weeks as we move to learn online. This post is more a reflection, and from my point of view, what could schools do next to tweak practice?
Nga mihi,
Mark
Thanks so much for sharing your experience here Mark and how you have empowered your own children to navigate their learning and the expectations they appear to have for themselves as well as those from the schools. This needs to be shared widely!
ReplyDeleteI also appreciate the challenges the adults in the household face while keeping up with your own jobs in a time when we are grateful to HAVE jobs and are juggling the competing demands for our time and attention.
I look forward to the video version of this :)
Kia ora Dorothy,
DeleteThank you for your comment. I am finding empowering my children is such tricky task however there have been such great learnings from it. Thankfully this week has started really smoothly with the structures and systems we set up working well.
Kia ora Mark, really appreciate your parent perspective. Understand that it is a reflection about your children and your family however very helpful to think about the complexities of managing learning when you are also working and have children at home. Admire and respect all parents who are navigating this 👏
ReplyDeleteNgā mihi nui,
Fiona (WFH w/ no children)
Thank you Fiona, I am certainly admiring my wife's ability to navigate three students learning including our Japanese student, as she is part time. I am not sure how to parents both working full time manage it.
DeleteKia ora Mark, Thank you for sharing your reflections, I can use some of your learning when I talk to my own team about Online and at-home learning. Like you, I appreciate the challenges of working at home with the whanau. We are in a better place to deliver learning, however, in has become more crucial to access and deliver teaching in an online and ubiquitous environment. All the best Mark.
ReplyDeleteKia ora Harry,
DeleteI can see the use of mystudentdashboard.com by your students especially in Year 9 and 10 as a real game changer for supporting their organisation of learning.
Hi Mark, its great to get a parent perspective. You have highlighted the need to look at and adjust to different styles of learning , and organising!I Hope we and the students learn from this and become more reflectful of their learning styles and allow for everyones diversity.
ReplyDeleteBy learning on line teaches have given so much agency to their pupils, maybe unknowingly,
from having control over time to think, do create and reflect in, even mute the teacher!
Your pondering questions are thought provoking and lead me to think how are we supporting parents at this time to help their children. All will be reveiled upon our return, when I'm sure feedback will come in many forms!
With your BOT hat on what questions will you be posing when "normal " returns?
Hi Mark,
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed reading this blog! I found your thoughts around your son's work very interesting, and could relate to them as I have come across similar experiences with my form class (year 10). This has led me to make a google doc for the class with all of their subject sites linked into the one space, I have also broken up some of the weeks worth of work into chunks so some of my more overwhelmed students can tick more things off! So I really agree with your points around multiple ways to organise their day, and the complexities of planning out time, when a weeks worth of activity is set at once for multiple subjects.
Thanks for sharing your views!
Mark
ReplyDeleteA great post... I think your experience reinforces the need for simplicity for learners... it resonates in the light of the Manaiakalani mantra 'limit the links'. I have circulated your blog to our whole staff team as damned god reading.
Hi Mark, it is really good to read a parent perspective - We are all doing our best to prepare effective and engaging distance learning programmes but your post has certainly made me stop and think. Remembering to consider the challenges faced by parents and students in this environment is really important - thanks for reminding me of this.
ReplyDeleteKia ora Mark, thanks so much for sharing your thinking, this is definitely a positive factor that has come out of this terrible pandemic! Teachers sharing their experiences and learnings under lockdown. You raise a number of pertinent points; one central place where learning can be accessed, limiting the links and scaffolding. I firmly believe we will come out of this pandemic situation with a greater understanding of effective teaching and learning practice! Kia kaha.
ReplyDeleteKia ora Mark,
ReplyDeleteThank you thank you thank you!! I wish I had read this post earlier, managing my own children's learning while supporting my class has been challenging to say the least. One child has kept the math and reading and given up his school's programme for everything else and is using our class's one for all sorts of reasons but mainly the challenges you had with you son but I couldn't work out a 'work-around' like you managed.
This has all made me think if we teachers are finding it challenging navigating other teachers ways of presenting learning, it must be jolly difficult for non- teaching parents.
Thank you for sharing your thinking